Converse pathways of soil evolution caused by tree uprooting: A synthesis from three regions with varying soil formation processes

P. Šamonil, P. Daněk, R. J. Schaetzl, V. Tejnecký, O. Drábek

Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

Abstract

Post-disturbance pedogenetic pathways were characterized in three landscapes representing different degrees of weathering and leaching. Tree uprooting has been the main form of disturbance in all three landscapes. We hypothesized that the pedogenetic effect of trees due to uprooting is mainly governed by the regional degree of pedogenesis, which in turn affects soil and landscape evolution. The three regions were characterized by a chronosequence of treethrow pit-mound pairs, from fresh to almost leveled forms. Two sequences originated from the Czech Republic, one on Haplic Cambisols and one on Entic Podzols. The third and the oldest chronosequence, in Michigan, USA, was on Albic Podzols (dating back to 4080 BCE). We analyzed 38 chemical and physical soil properties for 700 samples from 42 pit-mound pairs in these regions. Ordination and regression techniques allowed us to evaluate the effect of sample depth, microsite (pit, mound, and undisturbed control position), and age of the soils formed after uprooting. Depth was the most significant variable in all regions (p < 0.001), followed by microsite location, and then age (time since disturbance). The significance of these variables decreased with increasing weathering and leaching intensity. The results suggest that intense pedogenesis, as at the Michigan site, decreases the polygenetic impacts of uprooting on soil development pathways. On Haplic Cambisols, disturbances increased the local variability of pedogenic processes by changing melanization and hydromorphic processes, as well as by mineral alteration. Conversely, on Albic Podzols, we found comparative chemical uniformity in post-uprooting pedogenesis between microsites, despite rapid podzolization in pits and slower podzolization on mounds. The general chemical convergence of pedogenesis in these landscapes towards vertically-dominated podzolization may limit divergence of pedogenic pathways after a disturbance. The formation and translocation of labile organic matter-sesquioxide complexes in the uppermost podzolic horizons in Entic Podzolś was a key threshold, in that it changed the pedochemical, ecological and biogeomorphic role of the treethrow features in the soil and landscape evolution. Although treethrow pits were accumulation sites for soil elements in Haplic Cambisols and Entic Podzols, they were microsites of intense leaching and elemental loss in Albic Podzols.

LanguageEnglish (US)
Pages122-136
Number of pages15
JournalCatena
Volume161
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 1 2018

Profile

Podzol
disturbance
soil
soil formation
pedogenesis
podzolization
Cambisol
leaching
chemical
landscape evolution
chronosequence
weathering
effect
mineral alteration
ordination
translocation
soil property
divergence
organic matter
loss

Keywords

  • Cambisols
  • Chronofunctions
  • Ecosystem feedbacks
  • Pedogenesis
  • Podzols
  • Soil disturbance

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Earth-Surface Processes

Cite this

Converse pathways of soil evolution caused by tree uprooting : A synthesis from three regions with varying soil formation processes. / Šamonil, P.; Daněk, P.; Schaetzl, R. J.; Tejnecký, V.; Drábek, O.

In: Catena, Vol. 161, 01.02.2018, p. 122-136.

Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

@article{ae07839e5daa47599d8bda630b7e2669,
title = "Converse pathways of soil evolution caused by tree uprooting: A synthesis from three regions with varying soil formation processes",
abstract = "Post-disturbance pedogenetic pathways were characterized in three landscapes representing different degrees of weathering and leaching. Tree uprooting has been the main form of disturbance in all three landscapes. We hypothesized that the pedogenetic effect of trees due to uprooting is mainly governed by the regional degree of pedogenesis, which in turn affects soil and landscape evolution. The three regions were characterized by a chronosequence of treethrow pit-mound pairs, from fresh to almost leveled forms. Two sequences originated from the Czech Republic, one on Haplic Cambisols and one on Entic Podzols. The third and the oldest chronosequence, in Michigan, USA, was on Albic Podzols (dating back to 4080 BCE). We analyzed 38 chemical and physical soil properties for 700 samples from 42 pit-mound pairs in these regions. Ordination and regression techniques allowed us to evaluate the effect of sample depth, microsite (pit, mound, and undisturbed control position), and age of the soils formed after uprooting. Depth was the most significant variable in all regions (p < 0.001), followed by microsite location, and then age (time since disturbance). The significance of these variables decreased with increasing weathering and leaching intensity. The results suggest that intense pedogenesis, as at the Michigan site, decreases the polygenetic impacts of uprooting on soil development pathways. On Haplic Cambisols, disturbances increased the local variability of pedogenic processes by changing melanization and hydromorphic processes, as well as by mineral alteration. Conversely, on Albic Podzols, we found comparative chemical uniformity in post-uprooting pedogenesis between microsites, despite rapid podzolization in pits and slower podzolization on mounds. The general chemical convergence of pedogenesis in these landscapes towards vertically-dominated podzolization may limit divergence of pedogenic pathways after a disturbance. The formation and translocation of labile organic matter-sesquioxide complexes in the uppermost podzolic horizons in Entic Podzolś was a key threshold, in that it changed the pedochemical, ecological and biogeomorphic role of the treethrow features in the soil and landscape evolution. Although treethrow pits were accumulation sites for soil elements in Haplic Cambisols and Entic Podzols, they were microsites of intense leaching and elemental loss in Albic Podzols.",
keywords = "Cambisols, Chronofunctions, Ecosystem feedbacks, Pedogenesis, Podzols, Soil disturbance",
author = "P. Šamonil and P. Daněk and Schaetzl, {R. J.} and V. Tejnecký and O. Drábek",
year = "2018",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1016/j.catena.2017.09.032",
volume = "161",
pages = "122--136",
journal = "Catena",
issn = "0341-8162",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Converse pathways of soil evolution caused by tree uprooting

T2 - Catena

AU - Šamonil,P.

AU - Daněk,P.

AU - Schaetzl,R. J.

AU - Tejnecký,V.

AU - Drábek,O.

PY - 2018/2/1

Y1 - 2018/2/1

N2 - Post-disturbance pedogenetic pathways were characterized in three landscapes representing different degrees of weathering and leaching. Tree uprooting has been the main form of disturbance in all three landscapes. We hypothesized that the pedogenetic effect of trees due to uprooting is mainly governed by the regional degree of pedogenesis, which in turn affects soil and landscape evolution. The three regions were characterized by a chronosequence of treethrow pit-mound pairs, from fresh to almost leveled forms. Two sequences originated from the Czech Republic, one on Haplic Cambisols and one on Entic Podzols. The third and the oldest chronosequence, in Michigan, USA, was on Albic Podzols (dating back to 4080 BCE). We analyzed 38 chemical and physical soil properties for 700 samples from 42 pit-mound pairs in these regions. Ordination and regression techniques allowed us to evaluate the effect of sample depth, microsite (pit, mound, and undisturbed control position), and age of the soils formed after uprooting. Depth was the most significant variable in all regions (p < 0.001), followed by microsite location, and then age (time since disturbance). The significance of these variables decreased with increasing weathering and leaching intensity. The results suggest that intense pedogenesis, as at the Michigan site, decreases the polygenetic impacts of uprooting on soil development pathways. On Haplic Cambisols, disturbances increased the local variability of pedogenic processes by changing melanization and hydromorphic processes, as well as by mineral alteration. Conversely, on Albic Podzols, we found comparative chemical uniformity in post-uprooting pedogenesis between microsites, despite rapid podzolization in pits and slower podzolization on mounds. The general chemical convergence of pedogenesis in these landscapes towards vertically-dominated podzolization may limit divergence of pedogenic pathways after a disturbance. The formation and translocation of labile organic matter-sesquioxide complexes in the uppermost podzolic horizons in Entic Podzolś was a key threshold, in that it changed the pedochemical, ecological and biogeomorphic role of the treethrow features in the soil and landscape evolution. Although treethrow pits were accumulation sites for soil elements in Haplic Cambisols and Entic Podzols, they were microsites of intense leaching and elemental loss in Albic Podzols.

AB - Post-disturbance pedogenetic pathways were characterized in three landscapes representing different degrees of weathering and leaching. Tree uprooting has been the main form of disturbance in all three landscapes. We hypothesized that the pedogenetic effect of trees due to uprooting is mainly governed by the regional degree of pedogenesis, which in turn affects soil and landscape evolution. The three regions were characterized by a chronosequence of treethrow pit-mound pairs, from fresh to almost leveled forms. Two sequences originated from the Czech Republic, one on Haplic Cambisols and one on Entic Podzols. The third and the oldest chronosequence, in Michigan, USA, was on Albic Podzols (dating back to 4080 BCE). We analyzed 38 chemical and physical soil properties for 700 samples from 42 pit-mound pairs in these regions. Ordination and regression techniques allowed us to evaluate the effect of sample depth, microsite (pit, mound, and undisturbed control position), and age of the soils formed after uprooting. Depth was the most significant variable in all regions (p < 0.001), followed by microsite location, and then age (time since disturbance). The significance of these variables decreased with increasing weathering and leaching intensity. The results suggest that intense pedogenesis, as at the Michigan site, decreases the polygenetic impacts of uprooting on soil development pathways. On Haplic Cambisols, disturbances increased the local variability of pedogenic processes by changing melanization and hydromorphic processes, as well as by mineral alteration. Conversely, on Albic Podzols, we found comparative chemical uniformity in post-uprooting pedogenesis between microsites, despite rapid podzolization in pits and slower podzolization on mounds. The general chemical convergence of pedogenesis in these landscapes towards vertically-dominated podzolization may limit divergence of pedogenic pathways after a disturbance. The formation and translocation of labile organic matter-sesquioxide complexes in the uppermost podzolic horizons in Entic Podzolś was a key threshold, in that it changed the pedochemical, ecological and biogeomorphic role of the treethrow features in the soil and landscape evolution. Although treethrow pits were accumulation sites for soil elements in Haplic Cambisols and Entic Podzols, they were microsites of intense leaching and elemental loss in Albic Podzols.

KW - Cambisols

KW - Chronofunctions

KW - Ecosystem feedbacks

KW - Pedogenesis

KW - Podzols

KW - Soil disturbance

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85031705557&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85031705557&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.catena.2017.09.032

DO - 10.1016/j.catena.2017.09.032

M3 - Article

VL - 161

SP - 122

EP - 136

JO - Catena

JF - Catena

SN - 0341-8162

ER -